|
Which is more pertinent to a book about "mercenaries". This is about the vast right wing Christian conspiracy to take over the world for nefarious purposes.
Military's use of contractors deserves a serious study. Blackwater and the issues raised by the U.S.
Macbeth could have been talking about this book when he said: It is a tale Told by an idiot, full of sound and fury, Signifying nothing.For a book about the largest private military contractor and the man who leads it, you would think the author would give a little more than 4 lines to the fact that Erik Prince was a SEAL. Because, this isn't about Blackwater or the conundrum raised by PMC's.
Unfortunately, this isn't even a frivolous study of those issues, it is a biased diatribe obfuscating real debate. We get pages and pages about his grandfather, and not 1 word about Prince's 25 week SEAL training.
Why does Watergate figure and now prison evangelist Charles Colson get 2 1/2 pages more than Prince's training as an elite warrior.
If you want to learn about Blackwater and the role PMC play in Iraq then read "License to Kill." Avoid this book like the plague to learn anything other then marines are baby killers and all Iraq's are freedom loving freedom fighters. An antiwar diatribe that reveals the authors utter contempt for the Bush administration and the republican party. Book is fool of worthless political anti-war diatribe. What I got was a journalistic propaganda piece against the neocons and Bush foreign policy.
I really consider this a case where the author used the title Blackwater to draw attention to himself into fooling the reader into buying a book expecting an inside view and then really getting political diatribe. Scary and disheartening.BTW, what does Prince's Catholicism have to do with this topic other then a code word that if he is catholic, then it must be some evil right wing christian agenda. The author makes it a point to point out the conservatives religious affiliation as if this defines the illegitimacy of his view point. He seems not to describe the religious affiliation of those individuals with whom he intellectually agrees. I expected this to be in inside view of the world of Blackwater. Positives and negatives. The book is full of ad hominum attacks. I kept expected to be show some well thought out and researched positions other then four guys got killed in a war zone therefore this is all an evil Bush-Chaney con.If you want to learn about Blackwater or its founder Erik Prince, do not buy this book.
That is what was most disappointing. This is the level of political discussion in this book. This level of religious intolerance on the American left is both intellectually dishonest and shows quite a high level of intolerance for the other viewpoint. It says a lot about the low level of thought and discussion if the American liberal establishment considers this as up to snuff and a worthwhile read. Qualification such as "christian conservative" or "right wing" as if adding this adjective is more then enough to label the person and therefore no more detail is necessary as to why his position is incorrect.As to the subject matter, there is no analysis as to why privatization of the military is positive or negative other then it is promoted by Cheney et al. Actually made me mad enough to write this bad review that I wasted money on this propaganda hit piece.
An expose of the company. This rather shallow and poorly researched and obvious spin doctoring makes it quite unreadable.This is not a book about Blackwater but anti-war. That is the level of argument proposed in this book. That's all fine and dandy, but as much as I might agree with the author on his attacks against the Bush administration and its policies, I do not see how this has much to do with an expose about a company like Blackwater. I mean come on, a reader on such a hot button issue deserves a little more effort into this topic then if Cheney is for then it must be bad.
If you like the Shock Doctrine or Licensed to Kill, you will love Blackwater: The Rise of the World's Most Powerful Mercenary Army. This is an amazing story of how the worlds largest private army came to be.
in the Salvation Army bucket instead. Let's see, why could we not have figured this out BEFORE buying the book. The Evil American Empire will thank you even more. Your conscience will thank you. On the back cover offering their harmonic praise are (in no particular order) Michael Moore, Ali Baba, Michael Moore, Saddam, Osama, Madonna - you know these people.Did I mention Michael Moore. Friend, pass on this one and put 10 [.].
Instead, do yourself a favor and pick up Licensed To Kill by Robert Young Pelton. If you really care about reading an unbiased book about our military and private contractors, do not waste your time with this garbage. It isn't even worthy of being used as a doorstop. This book is pure, unadulterated crap. It was written by someone who actually has been there in the middle of everything, not hiding on the sidelines from a distance like that coward Scahill. I have seen many of his kook videos on youtube, and he really is a misguided little man. Jeremy Scahill is an anti-war, anti-military extremist trying to pass himself off as a credible journalist. He plays loose with real facts, and often makes up facts to support his views.
|
